Consciousness of Guilt and how it could become an issue in the Gabby Petito homicide
Recently and sadly, the remains of 22 year Gabby Petito were found in Wyoming’s Bridger-Teton National Forest. Now, the FBI and along with various other law enforcement agencies are looking for her fiancé, Brian Laundrie. Laundrie allegedly returned home to Florida without Petito three weeks ago. He has since disappeared and it is assumed at this point, if Laundrie is found alive, he will likely be considered the prime suspect in this homicide investigation. If Laundrie is alive and has the ability to contact anyone, investigators will consider his disappearance as consciousness of guilt that he killed Petito or conspired with some other person to do so. While this case is far from over, many forensic experts have speculated that it may be difficult to connect a suspect to this homicide and so investigator will likely have to use various pieces of circumstantial evidence to build a case.
Consciousness of guilt is one of the best prosecutorial devices available to an Assistant District Attorney (Prosecutor) in Pennsylvania or in any other jurisdiction like New Jersey where our criminal defense law firm defends person accused of offenses and crimes. Consciousness of guilt is circumstantial evidence of a crime which most people often fail to understand. Circumstantial evidence, unlike direct evidence, requires the trier of fact (judge or jury) to draw inferences after an event has already occurred.
What Type of Evidence Can Create A Consciousness of Guilt Argument?
Consciousness of guilt is the inference that the defendant knows that he is guilty of a crime because he has taken one or more of the following actions after it. These actions include:
- Fleeing from the crime scene or jurisdiction,
- False alibies,
- Changing or altering personal appearance,
- Hiding
- Destroying evidence,
- Bribing a witness,
- Intimidating a witness or even killing a witness.
In a criminal trial the District Attorney or prosecutor can show that this type of conduct was due to a defendant’s criminal conduct and it would have not occurred otherwise.
How It Can Hurt Your Chances at a Judge or Jury Trial?
Following a criminal trial a judge can give specific instructions on legal concepts such as consciousness of guilt, circumstantial evidence, direct evidence, and adverse inferences. The defendant has presumption of innocence and there is no adverse influence from him not testifying. A judge or jury, however, can draw an adverse inference if a defendant testifies or defendant takes actions prior to trial which imply guilt. The presumption of innocence, adverse inferences, and consciousness of guilt are all good reasons why the best course of action in criminal cases is that less is more.
The presumption of innocence argument is powerful instruction to the jury but an instruction regarding consciousness of guilt can substantially damage any defense. It can cause a jury to lose focus and center in on what an accused did following an incident when most people aren’t always in the best frame of mind. It is therefore extremely important that your criminal defense lawyer address conscious of guilt if it becomes a factor in your case.
The Most Common Criminal Cases For Consciousness of Guilt
While this concept can become an issue in virtually any criminal case, it often becomes in issue in violent felony crimes such as aggravated assault and robbery. Frequently in these cases, accused persons make attempts to destroy evidence (video surveillance tapes, audio recordings) and sometimes even attempt to contact the alleged victims. We also see this concept in non violent felony and misdemeanor offenses such as possession with Intent To Deliver Illegal Drugs and Narcotics or Driving Under the Influence Offenses. In these types of cases defendant’s typically attempt to hide their impairment or use of drugs to police.
What Can You Do To Prevent Conscious of Guilt
- Turn Yourself In With a Lawyer
- Don’t Run from Police
- Don’t Make A Statement (Verbal or Written)
- Don’t Be Rude To Police or Law Enforcement
For more great info on criminal defense strategies and concepts, I encourage you to keep reading this blog and visit my free download section
Contact Our Criminal Defense Lawyers in PA & NJ
Please click here to contact our Philadelphia criminal defense lawyers. We offer free case reviews and serve the following areas in Pennsylvania and New Jersey, Atlantic City, Camden, Cherry Hill, Chester, Conshohocken, Doylestown, Media, Norristown, Philadelphia, Pottstown, Salem, Upper Darby, Upper Merion, Upper Providence, Vineland & Woodbury areas.
