Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Judge Reinstates Murder Charges Against Former Police Officer – Why did the judge overrule the lower court? The difference between preliminary hearings and trials
The prosecutors argued that the lower court erred when that judge stated that the prosecution failed to present sufficient evidence at the preliminary hearing. The judge agreed with the prosecutors and reinstated the charges. The Court specifically stated that the defense had raised trial issues at a preliminary hearing. This case presents an opportunity to explain preliminary hearings in Pennsylvania.